Measuring Efficiency and Equity Framing in Economics Research


Using LLMs:

We measure how frontier research frames what is normatively at stake along the efficiency and equity dimension. We develop and validate an LLM-based measurement pipeline and apply it to 27,464 full-text journal articles from 1950 to 2021. Efficiency focused framing rises through the late 1980s, then declines as equity related framing expands after 1990, especially in applied work and policy evaluations. By 2021, papers with an equity component are about as common as papers framed purely around efficiency. President transmittal letters in the Economic Report of the President show a similar post 1990 shift toward equity, providing an external benchmark.

Here is the new NBER working paper by .  I take this to be a sign of radical decline in the quality of our profession.  I am all for welfare economics considering values other than efficiency.  How about liberty, opportunity, and merit?  Actual people, especially Americans, care about those too.  The longstanding focus on equity as the relevant alternative to efficiency is one of the most blatant politicizations of economic research you will find.  Most people doing it are not even aware of that, they simply take for granted that is the relevant trade-off.




Source link

  • Related Posts

    Photo essay: Southeast Asia’s overfishing crisis — and the effort to uncover its roots

    According to the Bronx Documentary Center, the photographs trace “the journey from local ports to global markets,” exposing the fragility — and human cost — behind seafood supply chains that…

    ‘Not the right time’: Retirees delay downsizing plans as housing market slumps

    The kids are moved out and all that extra space in the house just isn’t worth the upkeep. It’s an opportunity to move somewhere a little more practical, maybe a…

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    WATCH: What does a person have to make to afford the average price of a home?

    WATCH:  What does a person have to make to afford the average price of a home?

    Will human minds still be special in an age of AI? | Books

    Will human minds still be special in an age of AI? | Books

    Photo essay: Southeast Asia’s overfishing crisis — and the effort to uncover its roots

    Photo essay: Southeast Asia’s overfishing crisis — and the effort to uncover its roots

    Hear Me Out: These 5 Outdated Sandal Trends Should Be Skipped for 2026

    Hear Me Out: These 5 Outdated Sandal Trends Should Be Skipped for 2026

    Marco Rubio to visit Rome, reportedly to ‘thaw’ US relations with Italy | Marco Rubio

    Marco Rubio to visit Rome, reportedly to ‘thaw’ US relations with Italy | Marco Rubio

    Reform UK council backs release of beavers amid party row over rewilding | Reform UK

    Reform UK council backs release of beavers amid party row over rewilding | Reform UK