The Who What Wear office is basically one big fashion and beauty potluck. As a team of shopping-obsessed editors, we’re constantly swapping product recommendations, be it the trend-forward pieces that will elevate our fall wardrobes or the smoky perfumes that are destined for compliments. I typically return home with no less than three new items added to my cart (sorry to my wallet) and a bevy of styling tips to go along with them. All in a day’s work!

Recently, in between meetings, I innocently wondered aloud, “Has anyone tried the new Anfisa lip liners?” Immediately, I was met with an overflow of praise from the entire team. Oh my god, they’re so good. I’m obsessed. The shades are incredible. And when multiple editors come to the same conclusion without any prior discussion, that’s when I know an item’s a real winner. Of course, I’d been secretly using (and loving) the lip liners before their official debut on October 8, but after hearing the passionate reviews from my fellow coworkers, I’m convinced it’d be a sin not to share our full assessment. Below, discover each editor’s evaluation and the shade they personally can’t stop wearing. (Spoiler: A subtle, rosy-brown tint earns the majority vote!)

Judith Jones, Associate Shopping Director

Shade: Bruised Rhubarb