The Equal Pay Madness Just Got Madder


In my post Equality Act 2010 I discussed the UK’s absolutely insane wage policy:

In short, supply and demand have been replaced by judges and labor boards with the authority to deem which jobs are “equal” and therefore should be paid equally….No one is alleging that male and female warehouse workers were paid unequally or that male and female retail workers were paid unequally or that there was any direct or indirect discrimination. The only claim is that warehouse workers, who are less likely to be female than retail workers, earn more than retail workers. And since these jobs have been judged “equal,” the company has violated Equality Act 2010.

…The warehouse workers were almost 50% female (47.25%). So females were not barred from the higher paying jobs. The fact that 77.5% of the retail workers were female suggests that retail work has special appeal to females relative to males and thus that there are compensating differentials. Any of the three female plaintiffs could have taken jobs in the warehouse. If the jobs are equal and the warehouse jobs pay more this is, on the plaintiffs’ theory, “puzzling”. [Or, as Ayn Rand would say, blank out.]

In fact, the court case reveals that Next was struggling to fill the warehouse positions and offered any retail employee—including the plaintiffs—the opportunity to switch to warehouse work. On cross-examination, one of the plaintiffs admitted that, given the unpleasant conditions in the warehouse—described by the court as “the drone of machinery,…vibration, alarm sirens and the screeching of machinery, wheels and rollers, continuously present in all areas”—the warehouse job “did not seem particularly attractive” compared to the greater autonomy and more appealing environment of the retail job. The plaintiff added that she would only have considered the warehouse job if it paid “a lot more money.”

Well, here is the update. The outgoing Keir Starmer government is trying to massively expand these laws. The “equal value” framework previously applied only to sex discrimination; under the proposed law, employees could also bring equal-value claims based on race and disability. Remember, these laws have nothing to do with discrimination—they are about demanding, at the point of a gun, that apples and oranges sell for the same price because they’re both fruit.

The new law would also establish an Equal Pay Regulation and Enforcement Unit. As I said, Orwellian.

See also my post, How Britain Become as Poor as Mississippi.



Source link

  • Related Posts

    Nolan Wells Case: New Audio Sheds Light on Boat Malfunction

    IE 11 is not supported. For an optimal experience visit our site on another browser. Inside Look at Concerns Around Weight Loss Drug Overdoses 04:48 Record-Breaking 14-Foot Shark Appears Headed…

    Italian court begins delivering verdicts in trial over 2018 bridge collapse that killed dozens

    GENOA, Italy (AP) — Family members of the 43 people killed when Genoa’s Morandi highway bridge collapsed nearly eight years ago gathered at a courthouse Thursday, where verdicts were handed…

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    Markham is hosting an IndyCar race next month. Is the city ready?

    Markham is hosting an IndyCar race next month. Is the city ready?

    As Sustainability Concerns Rise, Consumers Favor Cotton as the Safest Fiber

    As Sustainability Concerns Rise, Consumers Favor Cotton as the Safest Fiber

    Move over, GPS: Navigation satellites in low-Earth orbit are making a comeback

    Move over, GPS: Navigation satellites in low-Earth orbit are making a comeback

    Buddhist monk: Herefordshire is the place to spiritually develop

    Buddhist monk: Herefordshire is the place to spiritually develop

    Nolan Wells Case: New Audio Sheds Light on Boat Malfunction

    Nolan Wells Case: New Audio Sheds Light on Boat Malfunction

    Ebola outbreak: Uganda starts 42-day countdown to being declared free of the virus

    Ebola outbreak: Uganda starts 42-day countdown to being declared free of the virus