Referees body admits error of judgement over Erling Haaland derby winner


Dale Johnson, BBC Sport football issues correspondent

The curiosity about this incident is that the goal was initially disallowed for the wrong reason. Haaland was flagged offside when he shouldn’t have been.

But as it turned out, the goal should have been ruled out because Fernandez was offside.

There is one key part of the offside law which applies to Fernandez here. A player is offside if they are:

“Clearly attempting to play a ball which is close when this action impacts on an opponent.”

Both parts of that clause must be met. It is possible for a player in an offside position to attempt to play a ball and not commit an offence – there must be impact on an opponent too.

As the ball came in, Fernandez threw himself to try to head it, with Martinez directly behind him.

Video assistant referee Matt Donohue should ask himself if Fernandez’s action would have influenced Martinez.

In other words: If Fernandez had not jumped for the attempted header, would Martinez have made a different decision over playing the ball?

If the ball had been out of reach for Fernandez, or for Martinez, then there is an argument to give the goal.

And also: There would have been no offside had Fernandez made no attempt to play the ball.

But he did. And as it went just a yard in front of Martinez too, it is very difficult to argue Fernandez did not commit an offside offence.

There is also an argument that the actions of Fernandez influence the positioning of goalkeeper Senne Lammens.

However, the goal was originally ruled out for offside against Haaland – which was incorrect. So that decision had to be overturned.

And then, the VAR should have sent referee Michael Oliver to the monitor for the subjective offence by Fernandez.

It would have created the odd situation where a disallowed goal was reviewed to remain ruled out – but this is what should have happened.

It was a clear offside offence by Fernandez and will go down as a VAR mistake.

Was the VAR too concerned with a possible touch by Fernandez?

If so, did the VAR forget that Fernandez was offside, and not consider the subjective offence? It seems to be the most logical explanation.

A similar thing happened in a game between Arsenal and Brentford in February 2023 when a goal by an offside Christian Norgaard was not disallowed.



Source link

  • Related Posts

    Steelers offense struggles vs. Falcons: Who’s to blame, what needs fixing

    Mike McCarthy’s debut as the Pittsburgh Steelers head coach will go down in the books as a 20-13 win over the Atlanta Falcons. However, the win was somewhat overshadowed by a highly…

    Continue reading
    Houston Astros swept in Tampa Bay ahead of final two weeks of regular season and AL West in doubt

    ST. PETERSBURG, Fla. – Jeremy Peña drifted under the pop-up and put his glove by his left ear for a catch the sure-handed shortstop will almost always finish. Third baseman…

    Continue reading

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    40 Years Later, Transformers Officially Embraces Its Most Heartbreaking Controversy

    40 Years Later, Transformers Officially Embraces Its Most Heartbreaking Controversy

    Steelers offense struggles vs. Falcons: Who’s to blame, what needs fixing

    Steelers offense struggles vs. Falcons: Who’s to blame, what needs fixing

    Insight Partners’ Devin Parekh on why the firm is diversifying while everyone else bets the farm on OpenAI and Anthropic

    Insight Partners’ Devin Parekh on why the firm is diversifying while everyone else bets the farm on OpenAI and Anthropic

    WATCH: US Open Men's final preview: Shelton vs. Zverev

    WATCH:  US Open Men's final preview: Shelton vs. Zverev

    Ahead of Fed meeting, Trump says US should have world’s lowest interest rate

    Ahead of Fed meeting, Trump says US should have world’s lowest interest rate

    Sam Altman Says OpenAI Won’t File For IPO This Year

    Sam Altman Says OpenAI Won’t File For IPO This Year