Reddit discussions across communities like r/grilling, r/BBQ, and r/smokers generally frame the debate between these two brands as a choice between “disposable convenience” and “long-term investment.” 

Charbroil (The budget-friendly option):

Overall consumer sentiment: Often categorized as “disposable but functional.”

Lifespan: Consensus suggests 3-4 years before major parts fail, though many users extend this to 8-10 years with diligent maintenance (covering the grill, cleaning the grease pan, and buying cheap aftermarket replacement parts).

Caveat: Reddit sentiment targets the brand overall rather than specific high-end models like the Pro Series, so individual performance may vary.

Weber (The long-term investment):

Overall consumer sentiment: Holds near-cult status for durability and longevity.

Lifespan: Users frequently share stories of grills lasting 20+ years, often with original parts still in use.

Note: Weber fans on Reddit often view the high upfront cost of a Weber as “cheaper” over time, arguing that one long-lasting Weber is more economical than replacing several budget grills over the same period.