Who is a victim?


Moral disagreement across politics revolves around the key question, “Who is a victim?” Twelve studies explain moral conflict with assumptions of vulnerability (AoVs): liberals and conservatives disagree about who is especially vulnerable to victimization, harm, and mistreatment. AoVs predict moral judgments, implicit attitudes, and charitable behavior—and explain the link between ideology and moral judgment (usually better than moral foundations). Four clusters of targets—the Environment, the Othered, the Powerful, and the Divine—explain many political debates, from immigration and policing to religion and racism. In general, liberals see vulnerability as group-based, dividing the moral world into groups of vulnerable victims and invulnerable oppressors. Conservatives downplay group-based differences, seeing vulnerability as more individual and evenly distributed. AoVs can be experimentally manipulated and causally impact moral evaluations. These results support a universal harm-based moral mind (Theory of Dyadic Morality): moral disagreement reflects different understandings of harm, not different foundations.

That is from a recent paper by Jake Womick, Emily Kubin, and Kurt Gray.  Via the excellent, non-victimized Kevin Lewis.

The post Who is a victim? appeared first on Marginal REVOLUTION.



Source link

  • Related Posts

    Japan Stocks Face Earnings Risk as Iran Conflict Lifts Oil Costs

    “It’s not just raw material prices — transportation costs will rise as well, and a global economic slowdown could curb demand,” NLI Research’s Ide said. Real wages, which recently turned…

    Bitcoin in Iran Limbo as ‘Old Economy’ Assets Steal Limelight

    Jeff Currie, chief strategy officer at Carlyle Energy Pathways, drew a comparison with the commodity boom that followed the dot-com bubble, a period he described as “the revenge of the…

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    Japan Stocks Face Earnings Risk as Iran Conflict Lifts Oil Costs

    More than 100 Labour MPs call on PM to stop assisted dying bill being blocked | Assisted dying

    More than 100 Labour MPs call on PM to stop assisted dying bill being blocked | Assisted dying

    India’s scattered workforce: the chatbot keeping families in touch during emergencies | Global development

    India’s scattered workforce: the chatbot keeping families in touch during emergencies | Global development

    One Battle After Another’s big night: Key takeaways from the 2026 Oscars | Arts and Culture News

    One Battle After Another’s big night: Key takeaways from the 2026 Oscars | Arts and Culture News

    Plans to cut NHS international workforce appear overambitious, say MPs | NHS

    Plans to cut NHS international workforce appear overambitious, say MPs | NHS

    Primal Season 3 Finale Review: Spear Vs… Everyone?

    Primal Season 3 Finale Review: Spear Vs… Everyone?