Premium Economy has quietly become one of the most compelling ways to use airline miles, especially for travelers flying long-haul routes from the United States. Sitting between standard economy and business class, premium economy promises extra legroom, better meals, priority services, and a noticeably improved experience — often at a fraction of the mileage cost of business class.

But with wildly different award pricing models and upgrade rules, the obvious question remains: which airline miles are actually best for booking premium economy in the US? The answer is not as straightforward as many travelers might hope. Premium economy is still a relatively young cabin in loyalty terms, and airlines have taken very different approaches to pricing and availability. Some programs offer semi-predictable award costs or mileage upgrades, while others rely entirely on dynamic pricing that can erase any sense of value. This article breaks down which airline miles currently offer the best opportunities for premium economy bookings from the US, focusing on the “big three” US carriers — American Airlines, Delta Air Lines, and United Airlines, alongside Air France–KLM Flying Blue and some other international airlines for better comparison and to understand the trends. It also explains when upgrading after booking economy makes more sense than redeeming miles outright.

What Are the Best Airline Miles For Booking Premium Economy From The US?

Credit: American Airlines | Simple Flying

The short answer is that there is no single mileage program that is always best, but some are far easier to extract value from than others. Air France–KLM Flying Blue and American Airlines AAdvantage consistently stand out for premium economy bookings, particularly on transatlantic routes. Both programs offer clearer pricing signals than most competitors, and both provide realistic paths to premium economy without requiring business-class-level mileage balances. If you are an American and need to travel to Europe frequently, you can also check European airlines like Air France—KLM.

Among US carriers, United MileagePlus can also deliver good value, especially when travelers upgrade from paid economy tickets rather than booking premium economy awards outright. Delta SkyMiles, on the other hand, is generally the weakest option for premium economy redemptions. While Delta’s premium economy product is competitive onboard, its fully dynamic award pricing often results in premium economy awards that are disproportionately expensive.

In practice, the “best” miles often depend less on the award price and more on booking strategy. Travelers who understand upgrade rules and cash-versus-mileage trade-offs usually do far better than those redeeming miles at face value. And of course, it depends on your frequent flyer status and the miles you accumulated.

What Factors Determine The Best Airline Miles For Premium Economy Flights?

Credit: Wikimedia Commons

Several key factors determine the best airline miles for booking premium economy from the United States, including redemption pricing, award availability, upgrade rules, partner networks, and route-specific cash fare differences. When breaking down premium economy upgrades in the US, these variables often matter more than the headline mileage number alone.

Travel patterns also play a significant role. Flyers who frequently book long-haul international trips may prioritize transatlantic or transpacific routes, while those purchasing economy tickets outright may focus on predictable mileage upgrades rather than full award redemptions. Fuel surcharges and co-pay requirements can also affect value, particularly on European carriers. Pricing structure is another major factor. American Airlines remains one of the few major carriers to publish saver-level award pricing for premium economy, with transatlantic awards priced at 40,000 miles one-way when available, based on its AAdvantage award charts.

By contrast, Delta Air Lines SkyMiles uses a fully dynamic model, meaning Premium Select awards often track cash fares rather than a fixed mileage tier, as reflected in Delta’s own award travel framework. Upgrade mechanics further complicate the picture. American allows mileage upgrades from eligible paid economy fares to premium economy on long-haul routes of 15,000 miles, subject to availability. United MileagePlus offers similar functionality through both mileage upgrades and PlusPoints, particularly on international routes operated by widebody aircraft with Premium Plus cabins. Delta, meanwhile, technically offers Mileage Upgrade Awards, but these are fare-class restricted and rarely available compared to cash-based upgrade offers, as outlined in its SkyMiles program rules.

Sources: thepointsguy, 10xtravel, AwardWallet

Award availability is also influenced by alliance and partner access. United’s participation in Star Alliance can increase the number of premium economy seats available on partner airlines, although availability varies by carrier and route. Air France–KLM Flying Blue benefits from close cooperation with Delta on transatlantic routes, sometimes allowing Flying Blue members to book premium economy for fewer miles than Delta charges for the same flights, particularly during monthly Promo Rewards.

In practice, these differences can be significant. For instance, Flying Blue Promo Rewards has periodically offered premium economy redemptions between New York and Paris for around 35,000 miles, while Delta SkyMiles has priced Premium Select awards on similar dates substantially higher under its dynamic model.

The World’s Most Comfortable Transatlantic Premium Economy Seats You Can Book Today

Discover the best premium economy seats to cross the Atlantic.

What Do Airlines And Travel Experts Say About Premium Economy Redemptions?

Credit: American Express

Experts like Point.me reportedly rank American AAdvantage highly for 2025 premium economy sweet spots, such as 40,000-mile transatlantic awards. Delta promotes SkyMiles for flexibility, with premium select upgrades often tied to cash values and fare-class restrictions, rarely as low as short-haul examples.

United highlights MileagePlus partnerships, with dynamic pricing yielding saver-level value on select international routes, such as ~56,600 miles on the route LAX– LHR. Air France Flying Blue officials have touted promo rewards as a key differentiator, while British Airways uses peak/off-peak pricing, which can increase costs, alongside high surcharges.

For travelers, this means monitoring monthly deals, influencing booking strategies, and encouraging credit card transfers for quick mile accumulation. Overall, experts agree that while devaluations like British Airways’ 10% hike challenge value, strategic use of partners and timing can maintain premium economy’s accessibility for US flyers.

Is Premium Economy A Better Use Of Miles Than Economy Or Business Class?

Credit: United Airlines

Premium economy most often competes with two alternative strategies: booking economy and upgrading later, or redeeming miles outright for business class. How premium economy stacks up depends heavily on how wide the pricing gaps are between these cabins and how predictable each airline’s upgrade system is.

On United Airlines, premium economy (Premium Plus) awards are frequently priced at roughly 1.4 to 1.6 times the mileage cost of economy class on long-haul international routes. This ratio is generally considered reasonable, particularly when business class awards are priced at two or even three times the cost of economy. In those cases, premium economy functions as a meaningful “middle ground,” offering a noticeably better seat and service without requiring a business class mileage balance.

American Airlines shows a similar pattern when saver-level premium economy awards are available. At 40,000 miles one way on transatlantic routes, premium economy often costs only modestly more than economy saver awards, while business class awards remain significantly higher. When availability aligns, premium economy is a more efficient use of miles than either upgrading economy or stretching for business class.

Delta SkyMiles presents a contrast. Premium Select awards often approach business class pricing, reducing the incentive to redeem miles for the intermediate cabin. In those cases, travelers may find better value by either staying in economy class or saving miles for business class on a different program.

Overall, premium economy performs best as an alternative when business class pricing escalates too sharply and economy upgrades are uncertain. Programs that preserve a clear mileage hierarchy between cabins, such as American AAdvantage, United MileagePlus (selectively), and Flying Blue, allow premium economy to fulfill its intended role. Programs that compress pricing between cabins, most notably Delta SkyMiles, reduce the usefulness of premium economy as a distinct redemption option.

Related

American Vs. Delta Vs. United: Which Carrier Has The Best Premium Economy?

These three airlines offer the most prominent premium economy offerings in the domestic aviation market.

Risks And Downsides Of Using Miles For Premium Economy

Credit: Air France

Despite the advantages, premium economy redemptions are not without drawbacks. Availability can be limited, particularly during peak travel seasons, and airlines may prioritize selling these seats for cash rather than releasing them as awards. Another risk lies in branding confusion. Some travelers mistakenly book extra-legroom economy seats, such as Economy Plus or Main Cabin Extra, thinking they are premium economy. These products lack the enhanced service, meals, and cabin separation that define true premium economy.

Finally, upgrade pricing can change after booking. Airlines like Delta frequently push cash upgrade offers via their apps, but prices fluctuate and may not represent good value. Travelers should monitor upgrade offers closely and compare them to outright mileage redemptions.

Final Analysis: Where Premium Economy Redemptions Still Make Sense

Credit: Shutterstock

So, which airline miles are best for booking premium economy in the US? For most travelers, Flying Blue miles offer the strongest combination of value, availability, and flexibility, especially for transatlantic routes. Among US carriers, United MileagePlus and American AAdvantage stand out for clearer upgrade paths and more reasonable mileage differentials compared to Delta SkyMiles. Ultimately, premium economy works best when approached strategically.

Booking economy and upgrading later, monitoring cash upgrade offers, and leveraging transferable points can all improve value. As airlines continue to refine their premium economy products, mileage redemptions in this cabin are likely to become even more nuanced.

Looking ahead, travelers should expect more dynamic pricing and targeted upgrade offers, particularly as premium economy cabins expand across fleets. For now, informed mileage use remains the key to enjoying a more comfortable flight without paying business class prices.