As the Maxx Crosby trade crumbles, Raiders and Ravens leave long line of people wanting answers

Maxx Crosby will want answers.

But the Las Vegas Raiders edge rusher — and yes, until further notice Crosby stunningly is still the Las Vegas Raiders’ edge rusher — will be the first but far from the last in line to hear them.

Because the Tuesday night combustion of the NFL’s biggest free agency news thus far does not only impact one player.

A flurry of activity crossed the NFL on Saturday, Sunday, Monday and Tuesday under the premise that a major domino had fallen Friday night when the Raiders agreed in principle to trade Crosby to the Baltimore Ravens for two first-round draft picks.

Then came the ominous Raiders tweet at 8:02 p.m. ET Tuesday: “The Baltimore Ravens have backed out of our trade agreement for Maxx Crosby. We will have no further comment at this time.”

Suddenly, dozens of puzzle pieces that had fallen into place during the league’s legal tampering window seemed slightly askew. Assumptions about the 2026 NFL power structure, about teams’ commitment to honoring their agreements, and about the definition of health in the league teetered.

Crosby did not immediately comment. But anyone who saw his 12-minute, 58-second goodbye to the Raiders, and celebration of his joining the Ravens, understood the severity of deflation he’s likely experiencing.

[Join or create a Yahoo Fantasy Baseball league for the 2026 MLB season]

Crosby did not pass his Ravens physical, according to multiple reports. The degree to which that “pass” is objective or subjective is debated, as team doctors vary in their risk appetite and willingness to factor in projected recoveries. But the medical hesitation that apparently blew up the trade drew suspicion across the league.

Teams wanted to know: Before the physical, who knew what?

HOUSTON, TEXAS - DECEMBER 21: Maxx Crosby #98 of the Las Vegas Raiders walks out of the tunnel before the game against the Houston Texans at NRG Stadium on December 21, 2025 in Houston, Texas. (Photo by Tim Warner/Getty Images) — Maxx Crosby remains a Raider heading into the beginning of the league’s new year. (Photo by Tim Warner/Getty Images)

(Tim Warner via Getty Images)

Crosby’s recent knee injury was not a secret. He underwent a meniscus repair on Jan. 7, per NFL Network, which projected a three- to four-month recovery timeline rather than a four- to six-week recovery had doctors only trimmed the meniscus. That timeline indicated the unlikelihood that Crosby would be fully medically cleared before the NFL league year turned over March 11. So what did the Ravens think his knee, or another area, would look like compared to what they saw?

Sources across NFL front offices viewed the likelihood of the Raiders intentionally misleading or omitting information from their medical report differently. One high-ranking NFC executive told Yahoo Sports they expected a high-priced trade like this would include the exchange of pre-surgery MRIs, post-operation notes, rehabilitation notes and more from doctors — all handed over to the Ravens before a trade could be agreed in principle. There should have been clarity, even if Crosby’s rehabilitation was not complete.

An AFC front-office source found the apparent disconnect between the two teams “fishy” while an NFC front-office source gave the Ravens more benefit of the doubt.

“It’s hard with a recent surgery until you see the player up close,” the NFC source told Yahoo Sports, speculating that the Ravens’ “extensive testing showed something LV didn’t want to disclose.”

As minutes ticked by Tuesday night, more questions than answers seemed to come.

Did the Raiders know something and mislead the Ravens? If so, did Crosby also know that information or was he kept in the dark?

Did Crosby’s physical actually resemble the general expectation of a player two months removed from a meniscus repair? If so, did the Ravens regret paying two first-round picks and decide they’d use their medical contingency to reverse course?

Thirty other NFL teams watched and wondered: Which of these teams, if either should we trust?

Suitors previously interested in Crosby wondered: How concerning is his knee, and should we again be interested?

Crosby’s agent, CJ LaBoy, tweeted that his client “continues to be on track in his recovery and if anything is ahead of schedule according to his surgeon Dr Neal El Attrache.”

So fans wonder: Would the Dallas Cowboys, who last week reportedly offered a first- and second-round pick for Crosby, circle back? The Cowboys responded to the Ravens trading two firsts for Crosby by trading a fourth-round pick for Green Bay Packers edge rusher Rashan Gary on Monday. No indication of a Cowboys renege came, but the possibilities beginning in Dallas and traveling beyond began to swirl.

What if the Carolina Panthers, who agreed Monday to a mega-payday with edge rusher Jaelan Phillips, decided they’d rather first try to get Crosby on a below-expectation price? Like Crosby, Phillips is a former first-round pick with injury history. He hasn’t reached Crosby’s level of production, but if the Panthers were willing to bet on Phillips’ health, might they be willing to bet on Crosby’s?

The Washington Commanders and Cincinnati Bengals signed Odafe Oweh and Boye Mafe to rush the passer under the assumption that Crosby was joining the Ravens.

The Ravens now need a pass rusher.

League officials had to be wondering whether their practice of trades and signings occurring days before they could be finalized Wednesday would create a larger firestorm.

Then came the onslaught of questions for the Raiders. Las Vegas doled out multiyear contracts worth more than $300 million this week to bring onboard center Tyler Linderbaum, linebacker Nakobe Dean, linebacker Quay Walker, defensive end Malcom Koonce, defensive end Kwity Paye, cornerback Eric Stokes, receiver Jalen Nailor and kicker Matt Gay.

Can they afford their handsome acquisitions alongside Crosby’s four-year, $106.5 million deal still on the books? Crosby’s $35.5 million average annual salary ranks sixth among edge rushers, per OverTheCap.com.

And is Crosby even still willing to play for the organization after their seven-year marriage ended acrimoniously, with the Raiders shutting down Crosby the final two weeks of the season and both sides marching toward a split?

Crosby was, and presumably is, ready to play for a contender rather than an interminable rebuild. He was, and presumably is, ready to leave beyond the team that managed just one winning season in his seven years as it cycled through five head coaches and wave after wave of dysfunction.

But who, now, might take Crosby?