Truthfully, if you had asked me even a few seasons ago if toe cleavage would become a thing again, I’m sure I would have dismissed it, but here we are. Stepping out in a glossy black pair of stiletto heels, Monica Barbaro brought back the divisive shoe trend all over again this week.

Styled with stovepipe jeans and a structured white corset top, Monica’s toe cleavage heels brought a nostalgic, Y2K-inspired energy into her outfit that felt perfectly in step with the season. Having largely disappeared from the spotlight after their heyday in the early 2000s, low-vamp heels have spent the past few years playing second fiddle to their opposite: high-vamp styles that cover more of the foot and lend a slightly more understated feel. But fashion has a habit of swinging back and forth, and what once felt entirely “out” inevitably finds its way back into our rotations.

It’s no secret that fashion has a fetish for freaky shoes. It’s not so long ago that we were reporting on five-toe flats and fluffy pairs—so the revival of the 2000s’ most popular “ugly” pair feels strangely inevitable.

Perhaps it’s the tongue-in-cheek nickname, but there’s something inherently playful about a shoe that embraces a little extra toe. A little provocative, a little nostalgic, low-vamp heels make summer outfits feel that bit more fun.

The trend may still be in its early stages, but I have a feeling it won’t stay under the radar for much longer. Read on to discover the best low-vamp heels to shop now.

Shop Low Vamp Heels: