2 former immigration judges sue Trump administration over their removal


Two former immigration judges have sued President Donald Trump’s administration over their removal, alleging they were discriminated against for political affiliation, sex, race, and past association with immigrant advocacy groups.

Carla Espinoza, a former judge in Chicago who was removed from her position with the Department of Justice last year, filed a lawsuit on Tuesday accusing the federal government of “firing” her based on her previous work as an immigration lawyer, as well as her race and sex.

Espinoza is one of 113 immigration judges who have been removed during the current Trump administration, according to the National Association of Immigration Judges. She was appointed as a judge in August 2023 and was dismissed this past August. 

According to the filing, DOJ’s Executive Office for Immigration Review began issuing memos in early 2025 that characterized immigrant advocacy organizations as “extremist” and promised to “penalize illegal DEI preferences.”

Espinoza alleges in the complaint that following policy shifts, the federal government “chose to fire from EOIR a disproportionate number of women, people of color, ethnic minorities, and persons associated therewith.”

A second former immigration judge who filed a lawsuit against the Trump administration last week alleged the federal government was motivated to remove her from her position because of her political affiliation, sex, age, race, and past association with immigrant advocacy groups.

PHOTO: Judge using a gavel in court.

The two former immigration judges were in temporary probationary periods and argue in their complaints that the DOJ had a policy and custom that upon the completion of a temporary term, the agency would routinely convert that probationary judge’s status to permanent immigration judge. 

Kyra Lilien, who was appointed as an immigration judge in 2023 and oversaw cases at the Concord Immigration Court in California, said her position ended in 2025 without the routine conversion to a permanent position.

According to the complaint, the federal government “began issuing numerous memoranda announcing the end to Diversity, Equity, and Inclusion (‘DEI’) efforts.”

“The memorandum stated that the Agency had reviewed the hiring materials of all Immigration Judges hired under the prior administration, and alleged that persons of ‘certain backgrounds’ were given favorable treatment over others,” Lilien’s attorneys said in the complaint. “The memorandum concluded that EOIR was ‘committed to rectifying those harms.’”

“Together, the memoranda laid bare management’s hostility to hiring individuals with immigrants’ rights backgrounds, women, ethnic minorities, and others who may be considered ‘DEI’ hires,” her attorneys said.

ABC News has reached out to the Department of Justice for comment.



Source link

  • Related Posts

    How college students are learning to socialize without cellphones

    NEW YORK — At the gate, guests slipped their phones into little cloth bags, putting them away for the evening. As the sunlight faded on a cobblestone street, more than…

    Live Updates: Candidates for California Governor Will Meet for Debate in L.A.

    For two hours on national television, seven candidates running for California governor wasted little time attacking one another on Tuesday night as they looked for memorable ways to differentiate themselves…

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    Champions League: Why Paris St-Germain pose ultimate test for Arsenal in Budapest final

    Champions League: Why Paris St-Germain pose ultimate test for Arsenal in Budapest final

    All Star Fox games that the new Star Fox game is technically a remake of

    All Star Fox games that the new Star Fox game is technically a remake of

    Best Kobe Shoes to Shop 2026: ‘Mambacita,’ Protro, Top Recovery Slides

    Best Kobe Shoes to Shop 2026: ‘Mambacita,’ Protro, Top Recovery Slides

    Cathie from Canada: Today’s News: Go Habs Go! Welcoming our new Governor General. And marking Red Dress Day

    Cathie from Canada: Today’s News: Go Habs Go! Welcoming our new Governor General. And marking Red Dress Day

    Hopes for reopening the Strait of Hormuz push Asian shares higher, as oil prices hold above $100

    Hopes for reopening the Strait of Hormuz push Asian shares higher, as oil prices hold above $100

    Call of the Wilde: Montreal Canadiens begin series against Buffalo with 4-2 loss – Montreal

    Call of the Wilde: Montreal Canadiens begin series against Buffalo with 4-2 loss – Montreal