Olivia Rodrigo used her “Saturday Night Live” double-duty night to sharpen the softer side of her style, which she has been heavily leaning into as she promotes her third studio album, “you seem pretty sad for a girl so in love.”

The singer hosted and performed as musical guest on the May 2 episode in New York City, moving between two pink satin shoes that sat on opposite ends of the same hyper-feminine spectrum.

Rodrigo kept the monologue look from tipping too sweet by leaning on proportion: a custom pale pink satin midi dress from Nina Ricci with a close-fitting corset bodice, visible vertical seaming and an elongated basque waistline, finished with Aquazzura’s Tell Me sandals.

The pink satin style featured a pointed open toe, a slim covered stiletto heel and a thin ankle strap with a small buckle. Three crystal-embellished satin bands criss-crossed across the vamp, giving the sandal a feminine, jewelry-like finish.

The “Drop Dead” performance pushed that softness into a different register. Rodrigo wore Miu Miu’s orchid-pink satin ballet flats with scrunched pale knee socks and a vintage 1920s lace and chiffon teddy camiknicker romper.

Rodrigo avoided the tidy ballerina read that often comes with satin flats. With the knee socks and vintage teddy romper, she pushed the Miu Miu pair somewhere messier and more specific: part bedroom vintage, part school-uniform styling, with the flat itself keeping the label’s familiar ballet vocabulary in view. Miu Miu’s version came in orchid-pink satin with a soft squared toe, a small bow at the vamp, a flat sole and a wide logo strap across the instep. She also performed a new track, “Begged.”

Rodrigo has been circling ballet-coded shoes for months, including green Miu Miu ballet flats with white knee socks at her American Express Platinum Card concert in New York City last October. She has also reached for Christian Louboutin’s Cassia Lace Up pump, a pointe-adjacent style with a squared toe and ankle ribbons. Those moments marked a softer counterpoint to the Dr. Martens boots, platforms and tougher schoolgirl codes that helped define her “Sour” and “Guts” wardrobes.

For this album cycle, Rodrigo has not abandoned that bite so much as she has filtered it through satin, socks, Mary Janes, bloomers and romantic vintage references. The “Drop Dead” video put her in Chloé and Versailles-coded styling, while her album artwork placed black Regent platform Mary Janes inside the same pretty-but-slightly-off world. On “SNL,” Rodrigo made the footwear thesis even cleaner: Aquazzura for the crystal-traced evening version, Miu Miu for the flat, girlish, romantically sweet version.