C.D.C. Cancels Publication of Study Showing Benefits of Covid Vaccines


The acting head of the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention has canceled the publication of a study that found that the Covid vaccine sharply cut the odds of hospitalizations and emergency visits last winter, a Health Department spokesman said.

Dr. Jay Bhattacharya, who has been overseeing the agency’s operations in the absence of a director, objected to the study’s design, saying it painted an inaccurate picture of the vaccine’s effectiveness.

The study, conducted by C.D.C. scientists, calculated the effectiveness of Covid shots by looking at the vaccination status of people who had sought care at hospitals and emergency rooms. It found that vaccination cut the likelihood of emergency visits due to Covid by 50 percent and of hospitalizations by 55 percent, according to a summary of the study viewed by The New York Times.

It was scheduled to be published on March 19 in The Morbidity and Mortality Weekly Report, the C.D.C.’s flagship journal. News of its cancellation was reported earlier by The Washington Post.

Some former C.D.C. officials said it was unusual for the head of the agency to cancel a scientific publication that had already been cleared by the agency’s staff scientists and had been scheduled for publication.

“I’ve never seen a case where an article in the M.M.W.R. that got to that stage was not published,” said Dr. Michael Iademarco, who led the center that included the publication’s operations from 2014 to 2022.

Andrew Nixon, a spokesman for the Department of Health and Human Services, said that “scientific reports are routinely reviewed at multiple levels to ensure they meet the highest standards before publication.”

He said that assessment “identified concerns regarding the methodological approach to estimating vaccine effectiveness, and the manuscript was not accepted for publication.”

The approach employed in this research has been used for years by scientists at the C.D.C. and elsewhere to gauge the real-world performance of flu and Covid vaccines, said Dr. Fiona Havers, a vaccine expert who resigned from the agency in June.

“It is really surprising that Jay Bhattacharya is now having issues with this methodology, since it has been a well-accepted standard for a long time,” she said.

A Health Department official, speaking on condition of anonymity to discuss internal agency matters, said Dr. Bhattacharya had met with the study’s authors but that they had not wanted to change its design.

Dr. Havers said it was impractical, if not impossible, to change the approach.

“The platform is designed in a certain way to collect data,” she said. “The data collection has happened, and they had done a full analysis using the methods that this platform has been using for years.”

The same method was also used in a study of the flu vaccine published last month. Had Dr. Bhattacharya been at the agency’s helm at that time, he would have raised objections to that report as well, the Health Department official said.



Source link

  • Related Posts

    Georgia Democratic Rep. David Scott dies at 80

    Veteran Democratic Rep. David Scott of Georgia has died. He was 80 years old. Scott, who served as the top Democrat on the House Agriculture Committee from 2021 to 2025,…

    Nearly half of U.S. kids are breathing unhealthy air, report says. These are the cleanest and most polluted cities.

    For 152 million Americans, including nearly half of the nation’s children and teens, just breathing air in the places they live can be harmful. According to the American Lung Association’s…

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    Milestone: American Airlines’ Boeing 737 MAX Fleet Hits 100 Aircraft

    Milestone: American Airlines’ Boeing 737 MAX Fleet Hits 100 Aircraft

    Georgia Democratic Rep. David Scott dies at 80

    Georgia Democratic Rep. David Scott dies at 80

    Virginia’s victory good for Democrats but also shows Trump’s redistricting battle could be all for nothing | US midterm elections 2026

    Virginia’s victory good for Democrats but also shows Trump’s redistricting battle could be all for nothing | US midterm elections 2026

    Premier League quiz: Name every manager departure this season

    Premier League quiz: Name every manager departure this season

    Vampire Survivors developer Poncle is opening more studios and has over 15 games in the works

    Vampire Survivors developer Poncle is opening more studios and has over 15 games in the works

    The exposed counties (from my email)

    The exposed counties (from my email)