Amazon has allegedly asked for the TV adaptation of Mass Effect to be rewritten to make it “more appealing to non-gamers”.

That’s according to The Ankler, which reports that the new head of global TV, Peter Friedlander, has asked to read the scripts of all in-development projects before awarding that all-important confirmatory green light.

As noted by IGN, this leaves the drama sci-fi series “on the verge” of a full order, leaving the production – and us – in limbo while we await a decision. It’s not clear what aspects of the script Freidlander thinks could put off those coming into the franchise for the first time.

Amazon’s Mass Effect TV adaptation was officially announced in November 2024. Last summer, it was revealed the Mass Effect series would be helmed by many of the team behind Amazon’s Fallout show, the incredibly successful game-to-TV adaptation that notably takes inspiration from the games without following them directly.

Casting details also leaked towards the end of last year: a young Colin Farrell-type male (30-39) with open ethnicity; a female co-lead alien character requiring prosthetics (34-39); a female human providing a parallel narrative from Earth; a Doug Jones-type male villain (40-60); and a male wrestler-type soldier (30-49). Amazon has provided no details about the show’s story, so it’s unclear whether it will be based on BioWare’s original Mass Effect trilogy or focus on entirely new characters in the same universe.

As fans attempted to match existing characters with the casting call, the Colin Farrell-type proved the most controversial. Fans have guessed this could be a male Commander Shepard, protagonist of the original trilogy, but this would suggest MaleShep is canon over the female option.