In the ever-changing landscape of nail trends, one aesthetic choice that I don’t foresee fading into obscurity anytime soon is the reflective finish. From the glazed donut nail trend that Hailey Bieber catapulted into a full-on viral frenzy to the recent revival of magnet-altered velvet nail polishes, trendy beauty lovers aren’t leaving the salon before turning their base colors into optical illusions. It’s not a question of whether you should get an eye-catching set right now but a matter of which kind.

My fellow Who What Wear beauty editors, friends, and I have seen a growing surge in cat-eye nails across the board, from icy, frosted iterations in the winter to softer versions in the spring. However, when we text each other our ideas before heading into our upcoming salon appointments, the color we keep landing on—whether for its neutrality, wardrobe versatility, or the fact that it’s downright pretty—is pink. However, celebrity manicurist Julie Kandalec has a theory.

Why Are Pink Cat-Eye Nails Trending?