I take my signature lip combo very seriously. Even though I’m constantly testing new balms, glosses, lipsticks, and liners to the point where each handbag has its own live-in product assortment, when it comes to an important event (or even a low-key dinner date), I don’t ever stray from my fail-safe lineup. So when I got married this November, you better believe I relied on my trusty trio: a creamy, matte lipstick, a non-sticky gloss, and the rosy-mauve liner I’ve worn down to the nub. I wanted to look like myself on my wedding day—of course my go-to “my lips but better” combo would make an appearance.

I handed my bridal makeup artist, Sophia Escobedo, the three items so she could work her magic, and when she did, she immediately marveled at the liner’s perfect shade of mauve. She told me she’d never seen a more natural-looking hue and (here’s the kicker) that she was immediately ordering it for her own kit. If that’s not a sign of a true winner, then I don’t know what is! Scroll ahead to shop the glorious liner for yourself, and know that I’m already restocking my all-time hero.

Photo of Jamie Schneider's makeup on her wedding day

The Lip Liner I Used on My Wedding Day (and Will Continue to Wear Every Day After)