Colin McGinn’s “My Honest Views”


I think David Lewis was off his rocker, I think Donald Davidson was far too impressed by elementary logic and decision theory, I think Willard Quine was a mediocre logician with some philosophical side-interests, I think Daniel Dennett never understood philosophy, I think Michael Dummett was a dimwit outside of his narrow specializations, I think P.F. Strawson struggled to understand much of philosophy, I think Gilbert Ryle was a classicist who wanted philosophy gone by any means necessary, I think Gareth Evans had no philosophical depth, I think John Searle was a philosophical lightweight, I think Jerry Fodor had no idea about philosophy and didn’t care, I think Saul Kripke was a mathematician with a passing interest in certain limited areas of philosophy, I think Hilary Putnam was a scientist-linguist who found philosophy incomprehensible, I think Ludwig Wittgenstein was a philosophical ignoramus too arrogant to learn some history, I think Bertrand Russell was only interested in skepticism, I think Gottlob Frege was a middling mathematician with no other philosophical interests, I think the positivists were well-meaning idiots, I think Edmund Husserl had no interest in anything outside his own consciousness, I think Martin Heidegger and John-Paul Sartre were mainly psychological politicians, I think John Austin was a scientifically illiterate language student, I think Noam Chomsky was neither a professional linguist nor a philosopher nor a psychologist but some sort of uneasy combination, I think the vast majority of current philosophers have no idea what philosophy is about and struggle to come to terms with it, I think philosophy has been a shambles since Descartes, I think Plato and Aristotle were philosophical preschoolers, I think no one has ever really grasped the nature of philosophical problems, I think the human brain is a hotbed of bad philosophy (and that is its great glory).

Here is the link, via The Browser.  My honest view is that he is worrying too much about other people, and not enough about issues.




Source link

  • Related Posts

    U.K. police leaders say they’re in touch with overseas law enforcement about Epstein files

    Thames Valley Police said this month that they were looking into a claim that the former prince, while he was serving as U.K. trade envoy in 2010, had shared sensitive…

    S&P/TSX composite rises more than 200 points helped by oil prices, U.S. markets slide

    TORONTO — Canada’s main stock index rose more than 200 points on Thursday, while U.S. markets lost ground. Source link

    Leave a Reply

    Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

    You Missed

    U.K. police leaders say they’re in touch with overseas law enforcement about Epstein files

    U.K. police leaders say they’re in touch with overseas law enforcement about Epstein files

    Federal NDP leadership hopefuls square off in English-language debate on Thursday

    The Pitt has a sharp take on AI

    The Pitt has a sharp take on AI

    Train! Stunt! Game! Denshattack! Has! A! Demo! On! Steam!

    Train! Stunt! Game! Denshattack! Has! A! Demo! On! Steam!

    Steve Cross, Former Neiman Marcus Men’s Footwear Buyer, Dies at 70

    Steve Cross, Former Neiman Marcus Men’s Footwear Buyer, Dies at 70

    British Police Arrest Former Prince Andrew, in Stunning Blow to Royal Family