Sorry to get all lit-nerd right after making fun of my fellow English majors, but if there’s one thing that feels central to the story of Wuthering Heights, it’s the fact that Heathcliff is supposed to be…hot! Life-ruiningly, psyche-invadingly, genre-definingly hot! No offense to Elordi, who is certainly as handsome and symmetrical as you might expect an A-list actor to be, but in the first glimpses we’re getting, his big, goofy grin, mutton chops, and gold tooth (!) just don’t evoke the wildness and sexual magnetism of Heathcliff’s character for me. Sorry!

Of course, the other thing to consider here is that Heathcliff is described by Emily Brontë as “dark-skinned.” While, yes, many period adaptations tend to be quite white, the popularity of Bridgerton proves that there’s plenty of room for actors of all races and ethnicities to get in on the corset-and-breeches-wearing fun. So, a wee bit of a missed opportunity, putting Elordi in the role—but maybe he’ll justify his casting in his actual performance? How much can we really know about a movie from long-range paparazzi shots, anyway?